Journal · Compliance

Reject all should be one click, here is why

8 May 20263 min readBy Walter Masseroni Gonzalez, Leon Aves, Daragh McCarthy and Alana Rossi

If accepting takes one click and rejecting takes three, your banner has a problem, one that regulators have already fined some of the largest companies on the internet for. The fix costs nothing, and in practice it tends to help consent rates rather than hurt them.

What regulators keep flagging

European data protection authorities have been consistent on this point for years: consent must be as easy to refuse as to give. France's CNIL fined Google and Facebook heavily in 2022 for exactly this asymmetry: a prominent accept button next to a refuse flow buried behind extra steps. In its cookie banner taskforce report, the EDPB recorded that most EU authorities see a layer offering accept with no way to refuse as falling short of the ePrivacy rules. A banner where rejection requires a trip through settings is not a grey area anymore.

Why dark patterns backfire

The tempting logic is simple: make rejecting harder, harvest more consent. In practice the tactic buys you three problems. The consent you collect is legally fragile, because consent obtained through obstruction does not meet the freely given standard. The measurement built on it inherits that fragility. And visitors are not fools: banners that feel manipulative get dismissed with whatever button is fastest, which is often reject when it is visible and accept when nothing else is. Random noise either way, not a decision. The honest levers work better, and we walk through them in how to raise accept rates without dark patterns.

What a fair banner looks like

A fair banner passes four checks:

  • Three options on the first layer, with equal weight: accept, reject and preferences.
  • Plain language about what data is used and why, not a wall of vendor jargon.
  • No pressure loops and no repeated prompts on every page view.
  • A way to change your mind later that is easy to find.

That is broadly what regulators describe, and it happens to be what visitors describe as respectful when you test it.

One clear choice, either way. No maze of toggles between you and no.

The counterintuitive part

Teams assume a visible reject button collapses consent rates. It does not have to. Clarity builds the kind of trust that makes people comfortable saying yes: a banner that reads like a sentence, states plainly what is measured and offers a genuine choice. People say yes to things they understand.

For the visitors who still say no, you respect the choice completely. Consent Mode v2 tells Google what they chose, and where your account meets Google's eligibility thresholds, modelled conversions estimate part of what they leave out. Declined visits stay out of your reports: modelling is an estimate, not a way around the choice.

Velo ships with reject all on the first layer by default. It is the right call legally, and it is the right call commercially.

Your next step in website privacy.

Your website privacy, in one place. Consent banners, records and scan findings with AI.

Common questions

Does reject all have to be one click under the GDPR?

Yes, whenever accepting takes one click. The law does not count clicks, but EU regulators read the GDPR consent standard and the ePrivacy rules to mean refusing must be as easy as accepting, so reject all belongs on the first layer with the same weight as accept all. France's CNIL fined Google and Facebook, in decisions announced in January 2022, because refusing took several extra steps.

Can reject all be a text link instead of a button?

A link is not ruled out on its own, but regulators judge whether refusing is as visible and as easy as accepting. A faint link tucked into the banner text beside a bright accept button is the pattern they flag. Two buttons of the same size and colour settle the question.

Does closing the banner count as rejecting cookies?

Closing or ignoring the banner is not consent. Until the visitor makes a choice, cookies and tags that need consent should stay off, so a close button works as a refusal for as long as no choice exists. If you show one, label it plainly so visitors know what it does.

Does a reject all button lower consent rates?

Against a banner that hides refusal, it can. That difference is consent you could not rely on anyway, because consent obtained by making refusal hard is not freely given. Plain wording and a genuine choice are the honest levers for accept rates, and a visitor who refuses should see no tags that need consent.

Keep reading


Start with a scan

See what your homepage already loads before you install anything. The free scanner reads the page and your public Tag Manager container.


A first pass, not a verdict. Four checks on your homepage, and we open your container.
V
Free scanNo account needed

Free for one site and 1,500 monthly sessions. Pro from €7 a month, plus VAT, for unlimited sites.

Step by step installs for WordPress, Shopify, Webflow, Wix and more.

Free for one site

Banner, scan and consent records for one site, free. Pro from €7 a month, plus VAT, for unlimited sites.